Can you all hear Prof. Horst alright?

I can!

Yes

Yay :-)

yes

yes

Yes

cant really hear what Prof Horst or the students are saying

Same ^

I had a question about Perusal. When I reply to someone else’s comment does that count as one comment? Or do I need to make five comments on the paper, independent from my replies to other students?

Same

It’s very muffled and echoy now

Oh its good now

it’s better now

Ok — helpful feedback! We’re trying — please keep the feedback coming.

@Tereza: yes, a response to someone else counts equally.

Great thanks!

Same as before — hard to hear the student’s comment?

yes

I couldn’t hear other students

yes^

but i can hear prof Horst fine

So elenchus is basically testing the other person just to make sure that what he is saying is correct/ right?

yes — though testing the ideas more than testing the person.

Yeah yeah okay thanks

Would it be possible to type what students say in the chat?

yes that would be really helpful

Sure: so far, we’ve had marketers, Trump, people campaigning in general, and lobbyists

Dr. Oz

Journalists

Thank u!

Sure — and remember if y’all want to jump in, just write it here and I’ll ask for you.

I’m not really hearing that clearly

does it depend on where he stands?

same, i think i cannot hear prof Horst clearly when he does not speak on the microphone in the stands

OK! He’s winding down — Prof. Irani and I will follow with shorter bits, and we’ll try to stick with the main mic.

Thank u!

Yes I think every time he turns away it gets a bit muffled

Thank you!

Yes!

So we are presuming what Kongzi would say to Callicles?

Thank you!

It seems we’re assuming it’s even worthwhile to transcend our own experiences as well. Likely “good” is defined by those experiences.

assuming both schools of philosophy are comparable

Thank you!

Thank you!

thank you

Thank you!

Thank you

Bye everyone!